Promotion Salary Increases: Moving Someone Into a New Range
A promotion is not a merit increase: the employee changes range. This guide covers sizing the increase, handling below-minimum cases, and documenting the decision.
Rovaryn Digital · November 10, 2026 · 8 min read

A promotion is approved, and the new range starts above the person's pay
On Thursday the department head signs off on a promotion. A senior analyst becomes an analytics lead, effective the first of next month. The title is settled, the level is settled, and the manager wants to tell the employee tomorrow. Then you open the pay file. The analyst earns less than the minimum of the lead range, because the old range was narrow and the new one was drawn a full level higher.
The manager asks the question you have heard before: "Can we just give them the usual increase?" The usual increase is the merit percentage from the last review cycle. Applied here, it would leave the new lead paid below the floor of the job they now hold, and below a new hire who joins at the bottom of that same range. Meanwhile, nobody has written down why this number and not another, so the next promotion will be argued from scratch.
This guide walks through a promotion salary increase in the order you would actually decide it: why it differs from a merit increase, how to size it against the new range, what to do when pay sits below the new minimum, and what to record so the decision holds up later.
Why a promotion changes the range, not just the pay
A merit increase moves someone within the range they already occupy. The job stays the same, the range stays the same, and the question is how far through that range a good performer should travel this year. A promotion answers a different question: what is the right pay for a different job?
Three things change at once. The employee's duties change. Their range changes, so the minimum, midpoint and maximum they are measured against all move. And their position in that range changes, even if their salary does not, because the same dollars look very different against a new midpoint.
That last point is the reason a flat percentage rule fails. Two employees who both earn the same salary and both get promoted into the same range can land in very different places, depending on where each started in the old one. A single rule that gives everyone the same percentage ignores the destination entirely.
If your ranges are built from clearly defined levels, the destination is easy to name. If they are not, start with our guide to job leveling for small businesses, and if you are unsure whether you are working with bands or grades, salary bands versus salary grades explains the difference. Both matter here, because you cannot place someone in a range you cannot define.
How to size a promotion salary increase against the new range
Start from the new range, not from the old salary. You need three numbers: the new minimum, the new midpoint and the new maximum. Then compute where the employee sits today, measured against the new range.
The standard measure is the compa-ratio: (current salary ÷ range midpoint) × 100. If the idea is new to you, compa-ratio explained covers it step by step. Run the formula twice, once against the old midpoint and once against the new one. The gap between the two results shows how far the promotion moves the person relative to their job.
Here is a worked example. Every figure below is an illustration chosen to show the arithmetic, not a benchmark and not a recommendation.
- Old range: $60,000 minimum, $70,000 midpoint, $80,000 maximum.
- New range: $75,000 minimum, $90,000 midpoint, $105,000 maximum.
- Employee's current pay: $68,000.
Against the old midpoint the employee's compa-ratio is ($68,000 ÷ $70,000) × 100, about 97. Against the new midpoint it is ($68,000 ÷ $90,000) × 100, about 76. The person has not lost anything, yet relative to the new job they are far below the middle of the range, and below its minimum.
Now there are three honest options to compare, each with its own cost and signal:
- Raise to the minimum. Move pay to $75,000, a $7,000 lift, or about 10.3% of current pay. This is the least you can do and still be inside the range.
- Place below the midpoint on purpose. Move pay to $80,000, a $12,000 lift, or about 17.6%. The compa-ratio becomes about 89, which leaves room to grow as the person proves out in the role.
- Place at the midpoint. Move pay to $90,000, a $22,000 lift, or about 32.4%. This usually belongs to someone who already performs at the new level and brings the full set of skills on day one.
The percentage is the output of the placement decision, not the input. A policy that starts from "promotions get X percent" will misplace people whenever their starting points differ. A policy that starts from "where in the new range does this person belong, and why" produces a percentage you can defend.
What to do when a promoted employee sits below the new range minimum
Below-minimum cases are the ones that stall approvals, so decide the rule once and write it down. The cleanest default is that nobody is paid under the minimum of the range for the job they hold, and the increase is at least enough to reach it.
Beyond the floor, you have a few levers. The most common is a staged approach: raise to the minimum or slightly above at promotion, then commit to a defined review point, for example after the first six months in the role, to move the person further if their performance warrants it. A second lever is placing the employee higher at the outset when their experience justifies it. A third is a wide new range paired with a clear placement rule, so that the lower third of the range is understood as the learning zone for someone stepping up.
Whatever you choose, check what the increase does to the people around the employee. A promoted analyst who jumps past a long-tenured peer in the same new range can create the kind of gap that causes resentment, and it is one of the ways pay compression starts. Look at who else sits in the destination range and compare their positions before you finalize the number.
Equity matters at this stage too. If promotions are placed by whoever argues loudest, similar employees can end up at different points in the range for reasons no one recorded. A written placement rule, applied the same way each time, is your best protection against that drift.
Writing the promotion pay policy down so it repeats
A written promotion salary increase policy does not need to be long. One page is enough if it answers the same questions every time:
- Floor. Is the new range minimum a hard floor on the effective date?
- Placement guidance. What evidence moves someone from the minimum toward the midpoint: experience, performance, scope of the new role?
- Ceiling. What approval is required to place someone above the midpoint, and who gives it?
- Timing. Does the increase take effect with the title, or does it wait for the next cycle? Waiting rarely holds up, because the person is doing the new job from day one.
- Overlap with merit. If a promotion lands near a review cycle, does the employee also receive a merit increase, or does the promotion replace it? State the answer so managers cannot negotiate it case by case.
Then record each decision as it is made: the old and new range, the compa-ratio before and after, the percentage and dollar change, the rationale in a sentence, and who approved it. That is what lets you answer a board member, an auditor or the employee a year later without reconstructing events from email.
Posting rules can also touch a promotion salary increase. Some pay transparency laws are written around advertised openings, and whether an internal promotion or transfer posting falls within a given law depends on the jurisdiction. If you employ people in New York, read our summary of the New York pay transparency law and confirm the details of promotion and transfer postings with the state labor department or your counsel. This article is not legal advice.
Tools that keep promotion decisions consistent
You can run all of this in a spreadsheet you build yourself, and many teams do. The weak point is usually not the formula but the repetition: each promotion gets a fresh, slightly different workbook, and the record ends up scattered.
The Promotion Increase & Range Movement Workbook is a structured template built for this decision. A promotion is not a merit increase: the person changes range, and the new minimum may already be above their current pay. It is a downloadable document you fill in by hand, and it pairs with a SalaryRange account rather than running inside it. If your levels are not defined yet, the Job Leveling Framework Template helps you define what each level means, then place your people against it.
Download the Promotion Increase & Range Movement Workbook to size your next promotion against the new range, or start with the Job Leveling Framework Template if the levels themselves still need defining.
Get new guides in your inbox
One email when a new article goes live. Unsubscribe with one click.


