HR Operations & Pay Equity

Setting a Merit Increase Budget at a Small Company

A merit budget is two decisions: how big the pool is and how it gets divided. This guide shows a small-company HR lead how to tie both to salary ranges and compa-ratio.

Rovaryn Digital · November 6, 2026 · 8 min read

Why a merit increase budget gets set in a hurry, and what it costs you

It is late in the year. The owner has asked what raises will cost next year, three managers have already hinted to their people that "something is coming," and the only data you have is a payroll export and a spreadsheet of last year's increases. Someone wants a percentage by Friday. You pick a number that feels reasonable, tell managers to "use their judgment," and hope it all adds up.

It rarely does. One manager gives everyone the same small raise to avoid awkward conversations. Another spends most of the pool on two favorites. A third discovers in January that the money ran out before the last three people were reviewed. Meanwhile an employee sitting near the bottom of their range gets the same percentage as a colleague already above the midpoint, and nobody can explain why.

None of this is a failure of effort. It is a failure of structure. A merit increase budget is two separate decisions made in order: how big the pool is, and how the pool is divided. Most small companies make the first decision carefully and skip the second entirely.

This guide walks through both decisions, shows how to tie the split to salary ranges and compa-ratio, and gives you a worked example you can copy into your own spreadsheet.

Decision one: sizing the pool

The pool is a dollar amount, usually expressed as a percentage of eligible payroll. Eligible payroll means the base salaries of everyone who will be reviewed in this cycle, which is not the same as total payroll. Exclude people hired too recently to be reviewed, people who have already received a promotion increase this cycle, and anyone on a separate pay plan.

Three inputs normally shape the percentage:

  • What the business can afford. Start with the finance conversation, not the market. Ask what total labor cost the plan can absorb, and remember that a base increase compounds: it carries into every future year, and into any payroll-linked costs.
  • What the market is doing. Salary-budget surveys from reputable compensation consultancies publish typical annual merit percentages. We do not publish a benchmark figure here, because the number moves from year to year and by industry. Pull the current one from a survey you trust and note its date in your cycle file.
  • What your ranges are doing. If your salary ranges are aging, people drift lower in their ranges even as they receive raises. Check how far the midpoints have moved from the market before deciding the pool is "enough." Our explainer on how the salary range midpoint works covers the mechanics of that check.

Keep the pool separate from other pay actions. Promotions, market adjustments for compressed roles, and counter-offers are different decisions with their own budgets. Mixing them into the merit pool hides what each one actually cost and makes the pool look overspent when it is not.

A worked example of a merit increase budget (illustrative numbers only)

The figures below are round inputs chosen to show the arithmetic. They are not a benchmark and not a recommendation for your company.

Suppose a company has 40 employees eligible for review, with combined base salaries of $3,000,000. Leadership decides the pool will be 3% of eligible payroll.

  • Pool = $3,000,000 × 0.03 = $90,000
  • Average dollars per eligible employee = $90,000 ÷ 40 = $2,250

That $2,250 average is only a planning figure. The point of the second decision is that nobody should actually receive "the average." Some people receive more, some less, and the matrix explains why.

Before you divide anything, hold back a reserve. Many small companies keep a modest slice of the pool unallocated until managers submit recommendations, so late corrections do not force a scramble. The reserve size is your call. Just decide it in advance and write it down.

Decision two: dividing the pool with a merit increase matrix

A merit increase matrix is a grid that turns two facts about an employee into a recommended raise percentage. One fact is performance. The other is where the person's pay sits in their range, measured by compa-ratio.

Compa-ratio is current salary divided by range midpoint, multiplied by 100. A person paid exactly at the midpoint has a compa-ratio of 100. Below 100 means below the midpoint, above 100 means above it. For a plain-language walkthrough, see compa-ratio explained.

Why include range position at all? Because the same percentage does different work at different points in a range. Someone near the bottom of the range who performs well is both a retention risk and a person with room to grow, so a larger increase moves them toward the midpoint where their pay is meant to land. Someone near the top has little room left before hitting the maximum, so a smaller percentage, or a lump sum that does not raise base, may be more appropriate. A flat percentage for everyone ignores that and slowly stretches the gap between pay and range.

A simple matrix has performance ratings down the left side and compa-ratio bands across the top. Here is an illustration, again with made-up percentages:

Performance Below 90 90 to 110 Above 110
Exceeds expectations 5% 4% 3%
Meets expectations 3.5% 2.5% 1.5%
Needs improvement 0% 0% 0%

Three design rules keep a matrix honest:

  1. Performance ordering holds in every column. A higher rating never produces a smaller percentage than a lower one in the same band.
  2. Lower range position earns more at the same rating. That is the whole reason the second axis exists.
  3. The matrix has to cost what the pool allows. Percentages that look sensible can still add up to more than the pool.

Testing the matrix against the pool before anyone sees it

This is the step small companies skip, and it is the one that prevents the January surprise. Run the matrix against your actual people, in a spreadsheet, before publishing it to managers.

For each eligible employee, you need salary, range midpoint, compa-ratio, and a provisional performance rating or a realistic distribution of ratings. Look up the matrix percentage, multiply by salary, and total the results. Then compare the total with the pool.

Take two employees from the example above. Employee A earns $54,000 in a range with a $60,000 midpoint, so the compa-ratio is 54,000 ÷ 60,000 × 100 = 90. Rated "meets expectations," A lands in the 90 to 110 column at 2.5%, which is $1,350. Employee B earns $66,000 in the same range, so the compa-ratio is 110. Rated "exceeds expectations," B falls in the 90 to 110 column at 4%, which is $2,640. B sits exactly on the band boundary, so you must state in writing whether 110 belongs in the middle band or the top band. Had it counted as the top band, B would get 3% ($1,980). That single boundary question, multiplied across a team, is exactly the sort of thing that produces inconsistent decisions.

If the total comes in over the pool, you have three honest options: lower the percentages across the grid, tighten the performance distribution you expect, or ask for a bigger pool. What you should not do is let managers discover the shortfall one by one. If the total comes in well under the pool, the matrix may be too timid, or you may have underestimated how many people sit below the midpoint.

It is also worth looking at the result by group, not just in total. Check that increases are distributed sensibly across teams, tenure, and demographic groups, and treat large unexplained differences as a prompt to investigate. A range penetration view helps here because it shows where everyone sits in their range at a glance, before and after the proposed increases. We describe implications only. If a pattern raises a legal question, take it to qualified employment counsel.

Rolling the budget out to managers without losing control

A well-built merit increase budget still fails if it is handed over loosely. A few practices keep it intact:

  • Give each manager a team budget, not the whole pool. Compute each team's share from the matrix applied to its own people, so the allocation reflects who actually sits where in their ranges. Avoid dividing the pool by headcount, which ignores range position entirely.
  • Make managers recommend within the matrix, with a documented band for exceptions. Allow a small amount of discretion, but require a written reason for anything outside the grid. The record is valuable if a decision is questioned later.
  • Route recommendations to one reviewer before anything is communicated. That person checks totals against each team budget and looks for outliers. Nobody should tell an employee a number until the consolidated view has been approved.
  • Keep a log. Record the final increase, the effective date, the approver, and the reason. A plain spreadsheet is enough if it is kept consistently.
  • Decide how to treat people at or above the range maximum. Common choices include a one-time lump sum that does not change base pay, or a range review if many people are bunched at the top. Whichever you choose, apply it to everyone.

Finally, review the cycle once it closes. Compare the budget you set with what you spent, and note which employees moved toward the midpoint and which did not. Next year's pool and matrix will be better for it.

Putting the numbers into a template

If you would rather not build the pool model and matrix from scratch, the Merit Increase Budget Modeling Workbook is a downloadable template to size a merit pool and spend it.

If you are running the whole review round rather than just the budget, the Salary Review Cycle Starter Bundle groups the cycle tools in one purchase. For more guides on pay operations, browse the HR operations resource hub.

Whichever route you take, the principle is the same. Set the pool deliberately, split it by a rule you can explain, test the rule against real people before launch, and keep a record. That turns a number picked on a Friday into a decision you can defend.

Ready to go beyond the guide?

Join the waitlist for Salary Range Builder.

See your ROI

How much is non-compliance costing you?

Browse templates

HR compensation templates, ready to download.

Get new guides in your inbox

One email when a new article goes live. Unsubscribe with one click.

More from HR Operations & Pay Equity